Analysis of Methodological Framework for Computer Strength Justification of Steel Structures at Operating NPP Units
ARTICLE PDF

Keywords

steel structures, methodology, strength analysis, life

How to Cite

Krytskyi, V., ShuhailoО., Matchenko, P., Krytska, N., & Matchenko, T. (2018). Analysis of Methodological Framework for Computer Strength Justification of Steel Structures at Operating NPP Units. Nuclear and Radiation Safety, (1(77), 31-41. https://doi.org/10.32918/nrs.2018.1(77).05

Abstract

Over the last decade, new national regulatory documents on the design and assessment of the technical state of building structures, in particular steel ones, have been put into force in Ukraine to replace relevant former USSR regulations. The experience of applying new national regulatory documents indicates certain incorrect provisions, which can potentially cause catastrophic consequences in case of failure of steel building structures of corresponding facilities and(or) hazardous production capacities. The paper presents the analysis of Ukrainian regulations to check compliance of available methodologies for computer strength justification of steel structures. It is established that current regulatory documents of Ukraine do not contain a description of methodologies and procedures (formulae) with regard to calculations of steel structures on resistance to brittle fracture and cyclic crack resistance. The analysis of a number of publications was performed to define methods for the calculation of steel structures to check endurance, cyclic crack resistance and resistance to brittle fracture.

https://doi.org/10.32918/nrs.2018.1(77).05
ARTICLE PDF

References

1. NP 306.2.141-2008. General Safety Provisions for Nuclear Power Plants. [Zahalni polozhennia bezpeky atomnykh stantsii], Kyiv, SNRIU, 2008, 58 p. (Ukr)

2. PiN AE-5.6. Structural Design Standards for NPPs with Different Reactor Types. [Normy stroitelnogo proektirovaniia AS s reaktorami razlichnogo tipa], Moscow, USSR Ministry of Nuclear Energy, 1986, 21 p. (Rus)

3. SOU NAEK 109:2016. Monitoring of NPP Building Structures. Basic Provisions. [Monitoring stroitelnykh konstruktsii AES. Osnovnyiie polozheniia], Kyiv, Energoatom Company, 2016, 48 p. (Rus)

4. DBN V.1.2—14-2009. General Principles of Ensuring Reliability and Structural Safety of Buildings, Constructions, Building Structures and Foundations. [Zahalni pryntsypy zabezpechennia nadiinosti ta konstruktyvnoi bezpeky budivel, sporud, budivelnykh konstruktsii ta osnov], Kyiv, Ministry of Regional Development, Building and Housing of Ukraine, 2009, 48 p. (Ukr)

5. DBN V.2.6—198:2014. Steel Structures. Design Standards. [Stalevi konstruktsii. Normy proektuvannia], Kyiv, Ministry of Regional Development, Building and Housing of Ukraine, 2014, 199 p. (Ukr)

6. DSTU B V.2.6-210:2016. Assessment of the Technical State of Operating Building Steel Structures. [Otsinka tekhnichnoho stanu budivelnykh stalevykh konstruktsii, shcho ekspluatuiutsia], Kyiv, Ministry of Regional Development, Building and Housing of Ukraine, 2016, 53 p. (Ukr)

7. NP 306.2.208 2016. Requirements for Seismic Resistant Design and Assessment of Seismic Safety of NPP Power Units. [Vymohy do seismostiikoho proektuvannia ta otsinky seismichnoi bezpeky enerhoblokiv atomnykh stantsii], Kyiv, SNRIU, 2016, 58 p. (Ukr)

8. DBN V.1.1-12-2014. Building in Seismic Regions of Ukraine. [Budivnytstvo u seismichnykh raionakh Ukrainy], Kyiv, Ministry of Regional Development, Building and Housing of Ukraine, 2014, 36 p. (Ukr)

9. DSTU B V.2.6-193:2013. Protection of Metal Structures against Corrosion. Design Requirements. [Zakhyst metalevykh konstruktsii vid korozii. Vymohy do proektuvannia], Kyiv, Ministry of Regional Development, Building and Housing of Ukraine, 2014, 199 p. (Ukr)

10. DBN V.1.2-2:2006. Loads and Hazards. [Navantazhennia i vplyvy], Kyiv, Ministry of Regional Development, Building and Housing of Ukraine, 2006, 60 p. (Ukr)

11. DSTU 2825-94. Strength Calculations and Testing. Terms and Definition of Main Notions. [Rozrakhunky ta vyprobuvannia na mitsnist. Terminy ta vyznachennia osnovnykh poniat], Kyiv, State Standards of Ukraine, 1994, 40 p. (Ukr)

12. Safety Series No. 50—80-811A. Accounting of Extreme Meteorological Phenomena in NPP Siting (without taking into account tropical cyclones). Safety Guide. [Seriia izdanii po bezopasnosti, No. 50—80-811A. Uchiot ekstremalnykh meteorologicheskikh yavlenii pri vybore ploshchadok AES (bez uchiota tropicheskikh tsyklonov. Rukovodstvo po bezopasnosti], Vienna, IAEA, 1983, 76 p. (Rus)

13. Safety Series No. 50-SG-S11B. Design Basis Tropical Cyclone for Nuclear Power Plants. A Safety Guide, Vienna, International Atomic Energy Agency, 1984, 56 p.

14. Safety Series No. NS-G-3.4. Accounting of Meteorological Phenomena in Assessment of NPP Sites. Safety Guide. [Seriia izdanii po bezopasnosti, No. NS-G-3.4. Uchiot meteorologicheskikh yavlenii pri otsenke ploshchadok dlia atomnykh elektrostantsii. Rukovodstvo po bezopasnosti], Vienna, IAEA, 2005, 36 p. (Rus)

15. Pinegin, S. V. (1969), “Contact Strength and Rolling Resistance” [Kontaktnaia prochnost i soprotivleniie kacheniiu], Moscow, Machine Building, 243 p. (Rus)

16. GOST 25.506-85. Strength Calculations and Testing. Methods of Mechanical Metal Testing. Definition of Crack Resistance Characteristics (Fracture Toughness) under Static Loads. [Raschioty i ispytaniia na prochnost. Metody mekhanicheskikh ispytanii metallov. Opredeleniie kharakteristik treshchinostoikosti (viazkosti razrusheniia) pri staticheskom nagruzhenii], Moscow, USSR State Standards, 1985, 38 p. (Rus)

17. DSTU 4484:2005/GOST 535-2005. Rolled Steel and Structural Steel Made of Usual Quality Carbon Steel. General Technical Specifications. [Prokat sortovyi i fasonnyi iz stali vuhletsevoi zvychainoi yakosti. Zahalni teknichni umovy], Kyiv, Ukrainian State Committee for Consumer Policy, 2008, 20 p. (Ukr)

18. DSTU GOST 7795:2008. Bolts with Hexagon Reduced Head and Underhead of Class B Accuracy. Design and Dimensions [Bolty s shestigrannoi umenshennoi golovkoi i napravliaiushchim podgolovkom klassa tochnosti B. Konstruktsiia i razmery], Ukraine State Standards, 2007, 15 p. (Rus)

19. DSTU GOST 15590:2008. Bolts with Hexagon Reduced Head and Underhead of Class C Accuracy. Design and Dimensions [Bolty s shestigrannoi umenshennoi golovkoi i napravliaiushchim podgolovkom klassa tochnosti C. Konstruktsiia i razmery], Moscow, USSR State Standards, 1970, 7 p. (Rus)

20. GOST 22356-77. High Strength Bolts and Nuts and Washers. [Bolty i gaiki vysokoprochnyie i shaiby], Moscow, USSR State Standards, 1977, 11 p. (Rus)

21. GOST 10705-80. Steel Welded Pipes. Technical Specifications. [Truby stalnyie elektrosvarnyie. Tekhnicheskiie usloviia], Moscow, Standards Publishing House, 2001, 11 p. (Rus)

22. GOST 10706-76. Steel Welded Longitudinal Pipes. Technical Specifications. [Truby stalnyie elektrosvarnyie priamoshovnyie. Tekhnicheskiie trebovaniia], Moscow, USSR State Standards, 1976, 9 p. (Rus)

23. GOST 8731-74 (ST SEV 1482-78). Steel Weldless Hot- Worked Tubes. Technical Specifications. [Truby stalnyie besshovnyie goriachedeformirovannyie. Tekhnicheskiie trebovaniia], Moscow, USSR State Standards, 1974, p. (Rus)

24. Matchenko, T. I. (2016), “Calculation of Operated Steel Structure Components for Static Strength and Resistance to Brittle Fracture” [Rozrakhunok stalevykh konstruktsii, shcho znakhodiatsia v ekspluatatsii, na statychnu mitsnist i opir krykhkomu ruinuvanniu], Science and Construction, No. 2(8), pp. 28—34. (Ukr)

25. Shamis, L. B. (2016), “Calculation of Bolt Joints for Cyclic Crack Resistance and Resistance to Brittle Fracture” [Rozrakhunok boltovykh ziednan na tsyklichnu trishchynostiikist i krykhku mitsnist], Construction in Ukraine, No. 1, pp 27—34. (Ukr)

26. Matchenko, T. I., Shamis, L. B., Matchenko, P. T. (2015), “Calculation of Welding Components of Steel Structures for Resistance and Cyclic Crack Resistance” [Rozrakhunok zvarnykh elementiv stalevykh konstruktsii na vytryvalist i tsyklichnu trishchynostiikist], Construction in Ukraine, No. 1, pp. 37—44. (Ukr)

27. Shuhailo, O. P., Matchenko, T. I., Matchenko, P. T., Liashenko, L. A., Panchenko, A. V. (2017), “Evaluating Approaches to Estimating Endurance and Cyclic Cracking Resistance of Metal Structure Components” [Analiz pidkhodiv do otsinky vytryvalosti ta tsyklichnoi trishchynostiikosti elementiv metalevykh konstruktsii], Nuclear and Radiation Safety Journal, No. 1(73), pp. 9—15. (Ukr)

28. Zubetsk, A. V., Matchenko, T. I., Yavorska, O. I. (2004), “Algorithm in Modeling of Fatigue Crack Progression in Structural Material” [Alhorytm modeliuvannia rozvytku trishchiny vtomy v konstruktsiinomu materiali], National Aviation University Scientific Journal, No. 3(21), pp. 137—145. (Ukr)

29. Matchenko, T. I., Matchenko, P. T. (2017), “Calculation of Welding Joints in Steel Structures Related to First and Second Groups According to Brittle and Ductile Fracture” [Rozrakhunok zvarnykh ziednan stalevykh konstruktsii, shcho vidnosiatsia do pershoi ta druhoi hrup za mozhlyvistiu krykhkoho ta viazkoho ruinuvannia], Collection of Scientific Efforts “Construction Operations”, No. 61, pp. 65—72. (Ukr)