Assessment of the Shelter Structures to Be Dismantled after NSC Installation. Comparative Analysis of Dismantling Options

Keywords

Chornobyl Shelter structures, technical condition, safety criteria

How to Cite

Nemchynov, Y., Bambura, A., Sazonova, I., Babik, K., Shcherbin, V., & Rudko, V. (2019). Assessment of the Shelter Structures to Be Dismantled after NSC Installation. Comparative Analysis of Dismantling Options. Nuclear and Radiation Safety, (1(81), 17-22. https://doi.org/10.32918/nrs.2019.1(81).03

Abstract

The surveys of the bearing and enclosing civil structures damaged after the Chornobyl Unit 4 accident that were conducted by the State Research Institute of Building Structures and Institute for Safety Problems of Nuclear Power Plants from 1995 to 2012 showed that a number of structures were in unstable condition. They include a group of structures that are especially dangerous in terms of the bearing capacity and are very likely to collapse. To ensure safe operation, immediate stabilization measures were developed and successfully implemented at the Shelter in 2005—2008. The justifying calculations show that the structures will comply with nuclear and radiation safety requirements (in terms of stability, bearing capacity etc.) over 15 years. The most unstable structures have to be dismantled by 2023, which is one of the conditions in the strategic plan for further transformation of the Shelter into a safe system. Two stages of safety measures have been defined for the unstable structures to be dismantled. The functional purpose of and climatic impacts on the bearing structures and, as a consequence, the Shelter lifetime are subject to change after stabilization of the unstable structures and installation of the New Safe Confinement (NSC) into the designed position. The paper analyzes scenarios for dismantling of unstable structures, stabilization measures and the probability of failure after implementation of the stabilization measures. A list of structures subject to early and deferred dismantling is provided. Shelter safety criteria and radiation protection objectives are considered.

https://doi.org/10.32918/nrs.2019.1(81).03

References

1. Law of Ukraine “On General Principles for Further Operation and Decommissioning of the Chernobyl Nuclear Power Plant and Transformation of the Destroyed Fourth Unit of the Chernobyl Nuclear Power Plant into an Environmentally Safe System” [Zakon Ukrainy Pro zagalni zasady posalshoii ekspluatatsii i zniattia z ekspluatatsii Chornobylskoii AES ta peretvorennia zruinovanogo chetvertogo energobloka tsiieii AES na ekologichno bezpechnu systemu], No. 2398-III of 26 April 2001, Bulletin of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine No. 4, p. 33. (1999) and Bulletin of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine No. 27, p. 133 (2001).

2. Procedure for Implementation of the Action Plan at the Shelter [Poriadok vypolneniia Plana osushchestvleniia mer na obekte Ukrytiie], Approved by Resolution of the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine No. 421 dated 31 March 2003, ZINAI, No. 18, p. 329 (2003).

3. Shelter Stabilization Strategy [Strategiia stabilizatsii stanu obekta Ukryttia], Kiev. 1997. Approved Decision of the Government Commission of 18 April 1997, Minutes No. 5, 27 p.

4. SIP-P-PM-21-330-EXN-004-01, rev. 2 dated 23 April 2004, Strategy for Further Implementation of the NSC Project [Strategiia dalneishei realizatsii proekta NBK], Supplement to NSC Explanatory Note SIP-K-0021 000-EXN-001 01 (KP) NSC.

5. SIP09-2-001 NI 03 RPT 036 07, rev. 07 dated 23 October 2013, D2.1 (3.7.41), Methodology for Reassessment of the Composition of Shelter Unstable Structures Subject to Early Dismantling [Metolologiia pereotsenki sostava nestabilnykh konstruktsii OU podlezhashchikh rannemu demontazhu], Chernobyl Nuclear Power Plant, NIISK-IPB

AES, 16 p. (2013).

6. SIP09-2-001 NI 03 RPT 037 05, rev. 05 dated 26 June 2014, D2.2 (3.7.42), Report on the Reassessment of the Composition of Shelter Unstable Structures Subject to Early Dismantling [Otchet o pereotsenke sostava nestabilnykh konstruktsii OU podlezhashchikh rannemu demontazhu], Chernobyl Nuclear Power Plant, NIISK — IPB AES, 2014, 60 p.

7. SIP09-2-001 NI 03 RPT 040 03, rev. 03 dated 31 August 2014, D4.2 (3.7.45), Report on Comparative Dose-Cost-Benefit Analysis for Two Options of Early Dismantling [Otchet o rezultatakh provedeniia sravnitelnogo analiza doz-zatrat-vygod dlia dwukh variantov rannego demontazha], NISIS — IPB AES, 79 p. (2014).

8. SIP09-2-001 NI 03 RPT 038 04, rev. 04 dated 31 August 2014, D3 (3.7.43), Analysis of Conceptual Design Solutions for the Early Dismantling of Shelter Unstable Structures Considering Two Options of Integrated Dismantling/Transformation and Dismantling with Deferred Transformation [Analiz kontseptualnykh proektnykh reshenii rannego demontazha nestabilnykh konstruktsii OU s uchetom dwukh variantov integrirovannogo demontazha/obrashcheniia i demontazha s otlozhennym obrashcheniiem], NIISK — IPB AES, 160 p., (2014).

9. SIP03 1 003 07 DCR-001 05, rev. 5 dated 11 March 2009, Design Criteria and Requirements for NSC Infrastructure for Dismantling of Shelter Unstable Structures [Proektnyie kriterii i trebovaniia k infrastrukture NBK dlia demontazha nestabilnykh konstruktsii obekta Ukrytiie], 2009, 170 p.

10. Technical Decision on the Choice of the Early Dismantling Option for the Development of Draft Project PC-2 NSC “Infrastructure for Dismantling of Shelter Unstable Structures” [Tekhnicheskoie resheniie o vybore variant rannego demontazha dlia razrabotki Rabochego proekta PK-2 NBK Infrastruktura dlia demontazha nestabilnykh konstruktsii OU], Reg. No. 09 of 2 February 2015, ChNPP General Director, 9 October, 2014; agreed by Chairman of the State Nuclear Regulatory Inspectorate on 22 January 2015, 7 p.
Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.